Brendon Hartley The 19th Driver of 2018 F1

In the high-stakes world of Formula 1, driver careers are often as fleeting as a single lap, and few teams epitomize this volatility quite like Scuderia Toro Rosso. Renowned for their role as a proving ground for Red Bull’s junior talent, the Italian outfit frequently navigates a landscape of rapid driver turnover. While some departures culminate in a coveted promotion, others end with the stark reality of being shown the door. The conclusion of the 2018 Formula 1 season perfectly encapsulated this dynamic, marking the end of Brendon Hartley’s tenure at Toro Rosso, a decision that unfolded amidst a season riddled with both promise and profound challenges.

Brendon Hartley’s journey with Toro Rosso was, from its very inception, an uphill battle. Having been plucked from the World Endurance Championship (WEC) to make his F1 debut late in 2017, the New Zealander was given a full-time seat for the 2018 season alongside fellow rookie Pierre Gasly. However, even before the final checkered flag of 2018 waved, rumors of his impending departure had become a persistent backdrop to his campaign. Hartley himself later admitted that the early season whispers about his future were a significant distraction, catching him by surprise and undoubtedly adding immense pressure to his performance. Ultimately, the speculation proved accurate, with Toro Rosso confirming his exit shortly after the season finale, paving the way for a new face in 2019.

Hartley’s 2018 season was, regrettably, defined by a series of unfortunate events and on-track struggles, particularly in the crucial opening races. In Bahrain, an early setback occurred when he received the team’s latest car upgrade a day later than his teammate, a seemingly minor detail that can have significant implications for car setup and confidence. His qualifying session was further hampered by an extraordinary incident: a bird strike to his car, which prevented him from joining Gasly in Q3. While Gasly went on to secure a sensational fourth place in the race – the team’s best result of the entire year – Hartley’s race unravelled. He inexplicably messed up the start protocol, incurring a penalty, and then compounded his woes with a collision involving Sergio Perez. This series of events set a dispiriting tone for what was to follow.

The challenges intensified in China. In a highly contentious incident, Hartley collided with his own teammate, Pierre Gasly, while attempting to let him through for the second time in the race. Such an error against a teammate is often heavily scrutinized within F1 teams, particularly when both drivers are vying for position and future career prospects. The situation worsened in Azerbaijan, where a terrifying near-miss in qualifying saw Hartley fail to notice Gasly approaching at high speed, almost sending his teammate airborne. These incidents not only cost the team valuable track time and potential points but also visibly strained the relationship between the two drivers, creating an uncomfortable atmosphere within the garage and on the track.

The deterioration of relations between Hartley and Gasly reached a critical point later in the season. In Brazil, despite explicit team demands, Gasly reportedly ignored instructions to let Hartley by, a clear indication of the fractured dynamics between the pair. This period was also overshadowed by increasing external pressure on Hartley’s seat. Rumors began circulating with significant intensity, suggesting that Toro Rosso was actively seeking to replace him, with McLaren junior driver Lando Norris being a prominent name linked to the seat. Adding to Hartley’s woes, a substantial crash during final practice at the Circuit de Catalunya forced him to miss qualifying, further impacting his standing and demonstrating a frustrating lack of consistent, clean running that is vital for establishing oneself in F1.

Despite the accumulating difficulties, it would be an oversight to attribute Hartley’s struggles solely to a lack of pace or skill. Indeed, Hartley was justified in highlighting a cruel string of misfortunes that consistently hindered his attempts to gain momentum and truly challenge his teammate. He suffered significant race-ending collisions in consecutive starts at Monaco and Montreal, taken out by Charles Leclerc and Lance Stroll respectively, incidents entirely beyond his control. A critical suspension failure at Silverstone caused another substantial crash, further impacting his budget for spare parts and potentially reducing his team’s trust in his ability to bring the car home clean. These mechanical and external incidents robbed him of crucial mileage, potential points, and opportunities to build confidence and rhythm.

Furthermore, an objective analysis of his raw speed reveals a more nuanced picture. His one-lap pace, when compared to the highly-rated Gasly, was surprisingly respectable. On average, there was only a tenth of a second separating them in qualifying, a testament to Hartley’s inherent speed. This competitive edge was briefly demonstrated in Germany, where he displayed his experience and race craft by overriding the team’s initial call for intermediate tires, opting for slicks and ultimately securing his second points finish of the year. This decision, though minor, underscored his ability to make astute calls under pressure. Another significant factor working against Hartley was the sheer volume of penalties incurred on his car by Toro Rosso throughout the season – a staggering eight, the most of any driver on the grid. These penalties, often for power unit component changes, frequently relegated him to the back of the grid, turning potential points-scoring weekends into damage limitation exercises before they even began.

However, even with these mitigating circumstances, Hartley was unable to consistently convert promising situations into significant points hauls. Hungary presented a particularly painful missed opportunity. Starting from an impressive eighth position on the grid, a strong points finish seemed within reach. Yet, he reversed out of the points during the race, eventually finishing outside the top ten, while Gasly capitalized, bagging a valuable sixth place. Mexico offered another squandered chance; after failing to reach Q3, Hartley became entangled with Esteban Ocon in the race, ending his hopes of a recovery drive and reinforcing the narrative of a season where opportunities slipped through his grasp.

His final statistical scoreline against Gasly was undoubtedly poor, painting a stark picture of the season’s outcome. Yet, it was arguably no worse than Daniil Kvyat’s performance against Carlos Sainz Jnr just 12 months prior, another Red Bull junior who faced a similar fate. This comparison begs a fundamental question about Toro Rosso’s strategy and commitment: why invest in a driver like Hartley, giving him a full season, only to seemingly abandon faith in him so quickly? This pattern suggests that the decision to replace Hartley might have been influenced as much by the internal team dynamics and his relationship with the team hierarchy as it was by his raw performance data. In the ruthless environment of Formula 1, especially within the Red Bull driver program, a lack of immediate, unequivocal results, combined with on-track incidents and a perception of internal friction, can quickly seal a driver’s fate, regardless of underlying potential or external misfortunes.

Go Ad-Free for Just £1 per Month>> Find out more and sign up

Your Verdict: Brendon Hartley’s 2018 Season

I don’t think I’m alone in desperately wanting Hartley to do well for some reason, but he clearly hasn’t cut the mustard this year. He’s had his share of misfortune, but has too often been much slower than Gasly.

Even his high points haven’t been much to shout about, scraping into the points only through retirements or disqualifications. I’m glad he got his chance, but won’t be too sad to see him go.
@Ben-n

What is your considered verdict on Brendon Hartley’s challenging 2018 Formula 1 season? Considering the blend of bad luck, on-track incidents, and moments of genuine pace, how do you assess his performance? Which drivers on the grid do you believe he performed better or worse than throughout the year? Share your insights and opinions in the comments section below.

Add your views on the other drivers here:

• Rate the F1 drivers of 2018: Your comprehensive verdict on the best and worst of the season

Advert | Become a RaceFans Supporter andGo Ad-Free

Explore More from the 2018 F1 Season Review

• Pass Masters: Discover Who Made F1’s Most Impressive Recovery Drives of 2018
• The Complete RaceFans 2018 F1 Season Review: An In-Depth Analysis
• Hamilton and Mercedes Triumph: Succeeding in Their Toughest Challenge Yet
• Vettel’s Costly Errors: How Blunders Thwarted Ferrari’s Title Hopes
• Financial Insights: An Analysis of How F1 Teams Spent $2.2 Billion in 2018

Browse All 2018 F1 Season Review Articles