Mercedes Pushes for FIA Review After Controversial Hamilton-Verstappen Sao Paulo Clash

In a move that has sent ripples through the Formula 1 paddock and captivated fans worldwide, Mercedes-AMG Petronas F1 Team has formally submitted a request to the FIA for a review of the contentious incident involving Lewis Hamilton and Max Verstappen on lap 48 of the Sao Paulo Grand Prix. This pivotal moment, which saw both championship protagonists run wide during a crucial overtaking manoeuvre, has become a focal point in an already thrilling and fiercely contested season.

The incident unfolded dramatically at the Descida do Lago corner, a left-hand bend notorious for its high-speed entry and the strategic options it presents for overtaking. As Hamilton attempted to seize the lead from his world championship rival on the outside of the corner, Verstappen defended aggressively. The consequence was both cars going off-track, with Verstappen appearing to carry Hamilton wide, forcing them both to bypass the corner and rejoin the circuit without a change in position. While the stewards initially noted the incident during the race, they ultimately decided against a full investigation, a decision that immediately sparked debate and drew sharp criticism from Mercedes.

The controversy deepened when FIA Formula 1 Race Director Michael Masi subsequently revealed that the stewards had not possessed access to crucial forward-facing cockpit footage from Verstappen’s car at the time of their initial no-investigation decision. This significant piece of evidence, providing a direct perspective from Verstappen’s cockpit, was released by Formula 1 only after the race, days later, altering the landscape of the discussion. Mercedes wasted no time in indicating their intention to leverage this newly available footage as a basis for a formal review, arguing it constitutes “new evidence” under the FIA’s International Sporting Code, warranting a re-evaluation of the incident.

The implications of a successful review could be profound for the 2021 Formula 1 World Championship, which is heading into its final races with an incredibly tight points battle between Hamilton and Verstappen. Should the stewards find Verstappen to have been at fault for running Hamilton off the track, and consequently impose a penalty, it would undoubtedly reshape the championship narrative. A five-second time penalty, retroactively applied to Sunday’s race result, would likely drop Verstappen from his second-place finish to third, costing him three crucial championship points. Alternatively, the stewards possess the authority to impose a grid penalty for the upcoming race, a precedent set earlier in the season when Verstappen received a grid penalty for his collision with Hamilton at the Italian Grand Prix in Monza.

Mercedes Team Principal Toto Wolff did not mince words following the race, vocally criticising the stewards’ initial decision not to investigate the incident. He famously described the call as “laughable,” reflecting the team’s strong belief that Verstappen’s actions constituted an unfair defence and warranted closer scrutiny. This sentiment underscored the growing tension between the two championship-contending teams and highlighted the subjective nature of racing incident assessments, particularly when high stakes are involved.

Michael Masi, while acknowledging the controversy, sought to clarify the stewards’ initial reasoning, explaining that their decision was made in accordance with the ‘let them race’ principles, which are agreed upon with teams to govern racing incidents. Masi elaborated on the various factors considered: “If you look [at the] proximity of the cars heading into the apex, where it is, nature of the corner, the fact both cars went off, neither car lost position, anything like that, that was probably the general view of it.” This philosophy encourages less intervention from race control unless a clear and undeniable breach of sporting regulations occurs, allowing drivers more freedom to battle on track.

However, Masi’s own comments hinted at the fine line between aggressive racing and unsporting conduct. He openly admitted that he considered showing Verstappen the black-and-white ‘unsporting conduct’ flag in reaction to the incident, a clear indication that the manoeuvre was on the edge of acceptable racing. “It certainly came into my mind, and then had sort of looked at it a few more times and it wasn’t far off a black and white flag, to be brutally honest,” he stated. Interestingly, Verstappen was indeed shown this very flag later in the same race for a different incident, further fuelling discussions about the consistency of stewarding decisions and the boundaries of fair play.

From the Red Bull Racing camp, sources indicated a degree of surprise at Mercedes’ decision to pursue a review, especially in light of Masi’s post-race comments and having also reviewed the new video footage from Verstappen’s car. Their stance suggests that they believe the incident was a racing incident, part of the cut and thrust of championship racing, and that the new footage does not fundamentally alter the interpretation that no wrongdoing occurred. This divergence in opinion sets the stage for a potentially heated hearing and further intensifies the already fierce rivalry between the two top teams.

The request for a review injects an unprecedented level of uncertainty into the final stages of the 2021 F1 season. Every point, every position, and every decision holds immense weight in this epic battle for supremacy. The FIA’s forthcoming hearing on Mercedes’ review request will be closely watched by fans, teams, and drivers alike, as its outcome could significantly impact the destiny of the world championship title. Whether the new evidence will be deemed compelling enough to overturn the initial decision remains to be seen, but one thing is clear: the drama surrounding the Hamilton-Verstappen rivalry is far from over.

Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter andgo ad-free

2021 Sao Paulo Grand Prix Related Coverage

• Red Bull and Mercedes summoned to FIA hearing on review of Sao Paulo incident
• McLaren must “get back to scoring the results that are on the table” – Seidl
• Hamilton makes his second-biggest climb to victory from 10th on the grid
• F1 releases missing video footage from Verstappen’s car of Hamilton incident
• How Alonso and Ocon “pushed team tactics to the ultimate limit” to delay Gasly

Browse all 2021 Sao Paulo Grand Prix articles