The highly competitive and often emotionally charged world of Formula 1 frequently throws up moments of intense drama, not just on the track but sometimes off it. One such memorable incident from the 2019 season involved Haas F1 Team Principal Guenther Steiner, who found himself under the scrutiny of the FIA for a radio outburst during the Russian Grand Prix. Following an investigation, Steiner was subsequently fined €7,500 by the sport’s governing body, a penalty that underscored the FIA’s commitment to upholding respect for officials and the integrity of motorsport.
Advert | Become a Supporter & go ad-free
The controversy ignited after Kevin Magnussen, one of Haas’s drivers, received a five-second time penalty during the race for rejoining the track incorrectly. The incident occurred after Magnussen went off at turn two, and his subsequent maneuver back onto the circuit was deemed unsafe by the race stewards. This decision profoundly impacted Magnussen’s race result, dropping him from what could have been a points-scoring position. Frustration boiled over for Steiner, a figure known for his candid and often fiery demeanor, leading him to express his displeasure in no uncertain terms over the team radio. His choice of words, which included labeling one of the stewards as “stupid” and “idiotic,” quickly became public, setting in motion an official inquiry by the FIA.
FIA Stewards’ Ruling on Guenther Steiner’s Conduct
The official ruling from the FIA stewards shed significant light on the context and gravity of Steiner’s actions. The document highlighted that during the Russian Grand Prix on September 29, 2019, a race counting towards the FIA Formula One World Championship, a panel of stewards imposed a five-second time penalty on one of the Haas F1 Team drivers, Kevin Magnussen. The ruling explicitly stated that the team principal of the Haas F1 Team, Mr. Guenther Steiner, who holds an FIA Super License, made critical comments regarding this decision in a radio message directed at the driver after the conclusion of the race.
The stewards’ report meticulously documented Steiner’s exact words: “…if we didn’t have a stupid idiotic steward we would be eighth… You know who is the steward. You know him. It is always the same. He just does not get any more intelligent…”. This uncensored message, transmitted over the team radio, was broadcast to the public. Its immediate dissemination across various media outlets, both in print and audio formats, amplified its impact and brought it to the attention of a global audience, making it a matter of public record and triggering the FIA’s subsequent investigation.
Due to the sensitive nature of the comments and potential conflicts, the stewards of the Russian Grand Prix referred the matter to the stewards of the Japanese Grand Prix. This delegation of authority was made in accordance with Article 11.9.3 t) of the International Sporting Code. The decision to delegate was pragmatic, primarily because certain members of the Haas F1 team had already departed the circuit, making an immediate hearing impractical. Furthermore, a potential conflict of interest arose with at least one member of the Russian Grand Prix steward panel, necessitating an impartial review by a separate body. This procedural step ensured that the investigation into Steiner’s conduct would be handled fairly and without bias, underscoring the FIA’s commitment to due process in disciplinary matters.
Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter andgo ad-free
On October 11, 2019, the delegated stewards conducted a formal hearing with Mr. Steiner to address the allegations. During this hearing, Steiner confirmed that his contentious comment was directed specifically at a single steward from the Russian Grand Prix panel, rather than the entire panel. He clarified that he did not intend to single out or malign other stewards involved in the decision-making process. Consequently, he raised no objection to the present panel hearing his case, even though its chairman had also served as the chairman at the Russian Grand Prix, accepting the impartiality of the new panel.
Steiner explained that his radio transmission occurred “in the heat of the moment,” immediately following a fiercely contested race by his drivers. He expressed regret for his choice of words, acknowledging their inappropriate nature in retrospect. He emphasized that his intention was not for his words to reflect unfavorably on the FIA officials overseeing the event and the championship. Despite his explanation and regret, the stewards determined that the broadcasted radio communication constituted a clear insult to the event’s officials. They noted that such statements directly called into question both the professional skills and the integrity of the stewards involved, which are foundational pillars of fair competition in Formula 1.
The ruling further stated that such public personal attacks against individual officials are “totally inappropriate and will not be accepted.” The stewards unequivocally highlighted that these types of statements inflict harm upon the reputation of motorsport in general and the FIA in particular, undermining the professionalism and credibility of its officials. While factual criticism of steward panel decisions is always welcomed in private discussions, the public and personal nature of Steiner’s comments crossed a clear boundary. The wording used by Mr. Steiner was deemed to have caused “moral injury to FIA officials” and was “prejudicial to the interests of motorsport,” thus constituting a breach of the rules as defined in Articles 12.1.1.c and 12.1.1.f of the International Sporting Code. As a holder of an FIA Super License, Mr. Steiner is explicitly subject to penalization by a fine, as stipulated in Articles 12.1.4, 12.2.1, and 12.4.1 of the International Sporting Code.
In determining the appropriate sanction, the stewards considered that Mr. Steiner had no prior penalties for similar behavior. This clean record influenced the decision to impose a fine of €7,500, which was deemed appropriate for the transgression. However, the ruling concluded with a stern warning: in the event of any future violations of this nature, the FIA may need to consider “harsher sanctions,” which could extend beyond the individual and potentially penalize the entire team involved. This serves as a clear precedent and a deterrent for all participants, reinforcing the FIA’s unwavering stance against disrespectful conduct towards its officials.
Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter andgo ad-free
The incident involving Guenther Steiner and the subsequent fine served as a stark reminder of the rigorous standards of conduct expected from all participants in Formula 1, especially those in leadership positions. While the sport is inherently passionate and competitive, the FIA maintains a firm stance on ensuring respect for its officials and the integrity of the decision-making process. Steiner’s public apology and expression of regret were acknowledged, yet the financial penalty underscored that even in the heat of the moment, professional decorum must be maintained. This ruling resonated across the F1 paddock, reinforcing the message that criticism, while sometimes warranted, must be channeled through appropriate channels and expressed with due respect for the individuals upholding the sport’s regulations. The episode ultimately highlighted the fine line between passionate advocacy for one’s team and behavior that can be deemed detrimental to the sport’s reputation.
2019 F1 season
- Crying in the Melbourne car park at 2019 grand prix was my career low – Ocon
- McLaren Racing reports reduced £71 million loss in 2019
- Kvyat: Hockenheim podium last year was “my biggest achievement” so far
- How the FIA’s new encrypted fuel flow meter targets Ferrari’s suspected ‘aliasing’ trick
- “He smashed my office door”: 23 must-see moments from ‘Drive to Survive’ season two
Browse all 2019 F1 season articles