The 2023 IndyCar season carved a unique chapter in the annals of American open-wheel racing. While the series is globally renowned for its fiercely competitive parity and championship battles often decided in the thrilling final moments of the last race, the past year witnessed an extraordinary and historic display of dominance by a single driver. Alex Palou emphatically secured the 2023 IndyCar title well before the season finale, a feat not accomplished since the reunification of American open-wheel racing in 2008. This exceptional performance by Palou set a new benchmark, making his inclusion at the top of our annual top 10 rankings an undeniable certainty for virtually every observer and fan.
Advert | Become a Supporter & go ad-free
The true challenge, therefore, lies not in identifying the champion, but in meticulously evaluating and ranking the formidable talents who filled positions two through ten. Despite Alex Palou’s individual mastery, the 2023 season was far from a one-man show, boasting an abundance of high-caliber drivers who delivered impressive performances in their own right, each contributing to a captivating and memorable year of racing. Our analysis delves deep into the nuances of each driver’s season, considering consistency, peak performance, challenges overcome, and their overall impact on the highly competitive IndyCar landscape.
10. Alexander Rossi
The tenth spot on our list was fiercely contested, with several deserving drivers making strong cases. Alexander Rossi ultimately earned his place following a remarkably solid inaugural season with McLaren’s third full-time entry. While his trophy cabinet for the year may only display a single podium finish and a notable absence from the front row of any starting grid, Rossi’s season was defined by a quiet, yet relentless, consistency. He amassed an impressive tally of six top-five finishes and an even more notable eleven top-ten results across the calendar. This steadfast performance stood in stark contrast to the initial struggles experienced by Felix Rosenqvist during his own maiden season with McLaren just two years prior, highlighting Rossi’s immediate adaptation and reliability within a new team environment.
Rossi has not yet fully recaptured the championship-contending form that defined his standout years at Andretti Autosport between 2018 and 2019. However, his 2023 campaign unequivocally laid a robust foundation for a resurgence, demonstrating a methodical approach and a clear objective to elevate his performance back to elite levels in the upcoming 2024 season. His consistency in 2023 suggests that with further integration and development within the McLaren framework, Rossi could once again become a regular threat at the sharp end of the grid.
9. Will Power
For a driver of Will Power’s caliber, a two-time series champion and the defending title holder entering the 2023 season, his championship defense was undeniably below his usual formidable standards. The year saw him achieve a mere four podium finishes and secure only two pole positions, statistics uncharacteristic of a driver renowned for his qualifying prowess and race-winning abilities. More strikingly, for the first time since his full debut season in the Champ Car World Series back in 2006, Power failed to register a single race win. These results, on the surface, might suggest the initial indications of a permanent decline for the 43-year-old veteran.
However, a deeper understanding of Power’s 2023 season reveals a narrative far more complex than mere performance statistics. It must be acknowledged that he was competing under extraordinarily difficult personal circumstances throughout the entire year. In January, his wife, Liz, was suddenly and gravely afflicted by an aggressive infection that targeted her spinal column, bringing her perilously close to death. The immense emotional and mental toll of this ordeal undeniably impacted his focus and performance during the early stages of the season. As Liz’s arduous recovery began to progress and show positive signs, a tangible improvement in Will’s on-track form became evident, particularly in the latter half of the year. This resilience in the face of immense personal adversity underscores not only his unwavering commitment to racing but also the profound human element that often influences even the most seasoned athletes. Considering these factors, his ability to still secure top-ten finishes and show flashes of his old speed is a testament to his mental fortitude.
Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter andgo ad-free
8. Kyle Kirkwood
The “Road to Indy” ladder system has historically produced a significant number of promising young talents, yet many graduates, upon reaching the pinnacle of IndyCar, have subsequently struggled to carve out impactful careers. This phenomenon has led to a degree of skepticism regarding the efficacy of domestic feeder series like Indy NXT, especially when compared to the often immediate and spectacular successes of drivers emerging from prestigious overseas junior formula ladders. However, Kyle Kirkwood stands as a powerful testament to the potential of the Road to Indy, arguably its greatest prospect in recent memory. Despite a challenging debut season with AJ Foyt Racing that led some observers to prematurely write him off, Kirkwood’s 2023 campaign served as a brilliant showcase of his true capabilities.
He delivered two stunning victories on the fiercely competitive street circuits of Long Beach and Nashville, demonstrating flashes of raw speed and race craft that few could match. While Kirkwood’s season also highlighted areas for improvement, particularly his tendency to be streaky and occasionally prone to accidents, his peak performances were undeniable. Crucially, he emerged as the standout performer within the Andretti Autosport team, which has, by its own high standards, struggled to find its consistent winning form in IndyCar over the past few years. Kirkwood’s ability to shine amidst his team’s broader challenges makes his achievements even more remarkable, signaling a bright future for the young American talent.
7. Marcus Ericsson
Marcus Ericsson’s 2023 season underscored his status as one of IndyCar’s most consistently strong and reliable competitors. He kicked off the year with a victory at the season opener in St. Petersburg, immediately signaling his intent. Furthermore, he was agonizingly close to securing back-to-back Indy 500 victories, missing out by a single lap due to what many considered a contentious, entertainment-driven decision from race director Kyle Novak. Throughout the season, Ericsson proved consistently adept across all disciplines of IndyCar racing, accumulating an impressive fourteen top-ten finishes. This consistent performance is particularly noteworthy given that he started from the front row only once during the entire year, often needing to navigate through traffic from deeper in the field.
While his absolute peak performances might not always reach the dizzying heights of some of IndyCar’s more flamboyant front-runners, his enduring consistency and ability to deliver strong results repeatedly belie his long-standing “Sneaky Swede” moniker. After four seasons with Chip Ganassi Racing, his form has been anything but ‘sneaky’; it has been as conspicuously brilliant and impactful as a Bonfire Night fireworks display. His rock-solid presence has made him a formidable opponent on any track. Following years of being categorized as a ‘pay driver’ early in his career, Ericsson’s consistent high-level performance was duly recognized, leading him to sign a lucrative multi-year deal with Andretti Autosport. This move not only secures his future as a highly paid talent in the series but also presents a significant opportunity for him to inject fresh energy and a winning mentality into a team that has, by its own lofty standards, been searching for renewed direction and consistent success.
6. Christian Lundgaard
Christian Lundgaard’s pole-to-win triumph at Toronto represented the undeniable culmination of a truly breakthrough 2023 season. Another promising alumnus of the Alpine Academy program, Lundgaard has, perhaps ironically, found profound success and established himself as a prominent talent not with the French manufacturer that nurtured him, but within the fiercely competitive IndyCar series. His performances predominantly on road and street courses were exceptional, placing him as the highest-ranked driver outside the traditional ‘power four’ teams, impressively securing ninth place in the overall standings solely based on these circuit types. This achievement speaks volumes about his inherent talent and adaptability.
Lundgaard’s stellar season was significantly highlighted by securing two pole positions and an impressive six ‘Fast Six’ appearances in qualifying, showcasing his consistent raw speed over a single lap. He also delivered eight top-ten finishes, often punching above the weight of his Rahal Letterman Lanigan Racing (RLL) team, which itself celebrated its first race win in three years thanks to Lundgaard’s Toronto masterclass. The Dane’s potential is immense; if RLL can successfully provide him with the comprehensive oval setups and the necessary confidence to consistently perform in this unique discipline, there is little doubt that Christian Lundgaard possesses all the attributes to evolve into a perennial IndyCar title contender, cementing his place among the sport’s elite.
Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter andgo ad-free
5. Josef Newgarden
The 2023 season marked a monumental turning point in the illustrious career of Josef Newgarden, as the two-time series champion finally conquered the elusive Indianapolis 500. This highly coveted victory, which had eluded him through eleven previous attempts, served to irrevocably cement his legacy as one of American open-wheel racing’s all-time greats, a remarkable achievement for a driver still only 33 years of age. Newgarden’s dominance on ovals throughout the year was simply flawless, delivering a perfect streak of victories until a singular misstep at Gateway. There, while fiercely contending for what would have been his fifth oval win, he unfortunately washed off the racing line and crashed, a rare blot on an otherwise pristine oval record.
However, a stark contrast emerged in his road and street course performances. A horrid late-season slump saw him tumble from second to fifth in the championship standings over the final four races. Prior to this downturn, Newgarden was once again in a familiar position, facing the daunting task of chasing a points leader from a considerable deficit to maintain any title aspirations. His form on road and street circuits dipped significantly in 2023, managing just a solitary podium finish at Road America in these events. This performance was undeniably below expectations for a driver widely and credibly regarded as one of the sport’s most versatile and best all-rounders, highlighting an area for significant improvement moving forward, despite his historic Indy 500 triumph.
4. Pato O’Ward
The performance trajectory of the McLaren IndyCar team often mirrors that of its dynamic star, Pato O’Ward. The 2023 season, for O’Ward, was a bittersweet symphony of undeniable speed, thrilling contention, and frustrating near-misses. He was tantalizingly close to opening the season with back-to-back victories; only a flash plenum fire and an ill-timed late-race Safety Car period prevented him from doing so. Despite these setbacks and ending the season as the lead driver in a win-less McLaren team, O’Ward’s sheer pace was consistently evident. He qualified in the coveted ‘Fast Six’ an impressive ten times throughout the year, underscoring his raw speed and ability to extract maximum performance from his car.
His seven podium finishes were the second-best tally among all IndyCar drivers, a testament to his consistent presence at the front of the field. Furthermore, in the final ten races of the season, O’Ward showcased remarkable consistency, never finishing outside the top ten. There is universal agreement that O’Ward possesses the extraordinary talent required to become a multi-time IndyCar champion and an all-time great of the sport. However, this vast potential often comes with a degree of frustration for fans and observers alike, particularly when instances of ‘red mist’ clouded his judgment at Long Beach, or when impatience led to costly crashes at Detroit and the squandering of a potential Indy 500 victory that could have easily been his. These moments, while few, highlight areas for mental refinement as he continues his ascent to the pinnacle of IndyCar racing.
3. Scott McLaughlin
Scott McLaughlin’s 2023 campaign saw him quietly ascend within the ranks of Team Penske, ultimately overtaking Josef Newgarden as the team’s top driver once the championship standings were finalized. He was one of only two drivers to complete every single racing lap this year, a testament to his exceptional consistency and control. His season peaked early with a compelling victory at Barber, a satisfying rematch against Romain Grosjean after their St. Petersburg duel had ended unsatisfyingly for both in a double knockout. McLaughlin appeared poised for a dominant pole-to-win performance at Nashville, only for ill-timed safety cars to disrupt his rhythm, forcing him to settle for a still-commendable second place. Beyond a challenging month of May at Indianapolis, which proved to be his only significant lapse after St. Pete, McLaughlin maintained an impressively high level of performance throughout the season.
What makes McLaughlin’s rapid rise truly remarkable is his background. A celebrated touring car convert, he arrived in IndyCar with virtually no prior single-seater experience. Yet, after just three full seasons, he is already knocking on the door of championship contention, consistently challenging the series’ most seasoned veterans. This extraordinary adaptation and consistent improvement, even with the considerable resources of Team Penske at his disposal, is a unique narrative in modern motorsport. It speaks volumes about his raw talent, dedication, and ability to quickly master the distinct demands of IndyCar racing, establishing him as a genuine threat for future titles.
Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter andgo ad-free
2. Scott Dixon
The third race of the 2023 IndyCar season at Long Beach saw a rare misstep for Scott Dixon, as he was aggressively pushed into the tire barriers by a desperate Pato O’Ward while battling for sixth position. He later retired from the race due to a mechanical failure, marking his first retirement in an incredible 23 races. This singular incident, an uncharacteristic blemish on his record, proved to be the only major imperfection in what was otherwise another masterclass season for the six-time IndyCar champion. Dixon’s 2023 campaign concluded with a spectacular flourish, securing three victories in the final four races, a testament to his unparalleled ability to extract performance when it matters most.
While this late-season surge wasn’t quite enough to orchestrate a historic championship reversal, it allowed him to solidify a commanding second place in the championship standings, well out of reach of his closest competitors. More significantly, it extended his truly astonishing 19-year streak of consecutive seasons with at least one race win, an achievement that highlights his enduring brilliance and longevity in the sport. His ability to consistently win, year after year, further punctuates an otherwise brilliant 2023 season, underscoring why he is known as ‘The Iceman’.
Highlights of Dixon’s season were numerous and spectacular. At the summer race on the Indianapolis road course, he famously recovered from a first-lap spin to snatch victory from Graham Rahal’s grasp in the closing stages, showcasing his legendary composure and race craft. He then delivered another typical Dixon masterclass of fuel management to win at Gateway from a lowly 16th on the grid, an exhibition of strategic genius. The season was capped off by an incredible victory at Laguna Seca, where he overcame a harsh penalty for avoidable contact by executing a brilliant alternate strategy. Not to be forgotten was his methodical drive from 23rd to an impressive fourth place at Road America, another display of his ability to dissect a field.
If one were to exclude that unfortunate result at Long Beach, Dixon’s worst finish of the season would have been a highly respectable seventh place at Barber Motorsports Park. This would have translated to an astonishing average finishing position of a mere 4.0. In almost any other IndyCar season, such a consistent and dominant performance would have been more than sufficient for Dixon to comfortably walk away with a record-equaling seventh IndyCar title, a testament to the sheer scale of Palou’s unprecedented dominance.
1. Alex Palou
Alex Palou’s 2023 IndyCar season was an absolute masterclass, a performance so overwhelmingly dominant that the sport has not witnessed its like in many years. He truly was in a class of his own, redefining what is possible in a series built upon the principles of competitive parity and technical uniformity.
The statistics he amassed are nothing short of stunning and paint a vivid picture of his supremacy: Five outright victories, including an incandescent run of four wins in just five races, stretching from the spring Indianapolis road course event all the way to Mid-Ohio. He collected an astounding ten podium finishes, consistently placing himself in contention for the win. His raw qualifying speed was equally impressive, with ten ‘Fast Six’ appearances. Perhaps most telling of his unwavering consistency and impeccable race craft is the fact that he never once finished lower than eighth place throughout the entire grueling season. Furthermore, he led a staggering 320 laps on road and street courses alone, more than double the amount of the next best driver in these disciplines, showcasing his ability to not only get to the front but also control races from there.
In a series intentionally designed with spec chassis, where competitive parity is a core tenet and only damper technology and engine development remain open for significant innovation, Alex Palou’s achievement is even more profound. He posted an astonishing average finishing position of 3.71, a figure unheard of in such a closely matched field. This exceptional performance allowed him to become the first driver since the 2008 reunification of the sport to clinch the series championship before the final race, a testament to the sheer, unassailable lead he built.
Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter andgo ad-free
And yet, his season could have been even more legendary. Palou reset the record for the fastest Indianapolis 500 pole qualifying run in history, demonstrating incredible speed at the Brickyard. He then rallied back to an impressive fourth-place finish in the race itself, despite an unfortunate incident where Rinus VeeKay spun into him at the exit of pit lane. Had it not been for that unforeseen occurrence, Palou might very well have had his face engraved into the iconic Borg-Warner Trophy, adding the ultimate prize to his already dominant season.
He achieved all of this with an otherworldly pace, coupled with an intelligence and strategic savvy that belied his mere 26 years of age. While ovals are often cited as his lone perceived deficiency, many drivers would eagerly exchange their oval results for the kind of consistent, top-tier performances Palou posted in those five oval races. On the rare occasions where he didn’t qualify within the first three rows, he consistently found a way to carve through the field and move forward, demonstrating his exceptional race craft and ability to adapt. Alex Palou’s 2023 season was not just a championship-winning year; it was a masterclass that will be studied and remembered for generations, setting a new standard for dominance in modern IndyCar racing.
Those who didn’t make the cut
Several other drivers delivered noteworthy performances in the 2023 IndyCar season, narrowly missing out on a spot in our top ten but nonetheless making a significant impact. Graham Rahal experienced a rollercoaster year that began with the profound disappointment of missing the Indianapolis 500 field, only to re-enter the race as a substitute for the injured Stefan Wilson. Following this dramatic start, Rahal and his Rahal Letterman Lanigan Racing team truly turned a corner, especially on road and street circuits, where he put together some of his most competitive weekends in recent memory, showing renewed pace and challenging at the front.
Felix Rosenqvist, in his final season with McLaren, often demonstrated flashes of exceptional speed, securing two poles and two podium finishes. These moments highlighted the raw talent that, at times, went unrewarded during his turbulent three-year tenure with the team. Now, he faces the formidable task of revitalizing Meyer Shank Racing’s fortunes in 2024, a significant challenge given their recent struggles. His replacement at McLaren, David Malukas, showed promising raw pace throughout the season, albeit with some lingering inconsistencies. However, his undeniable speed was enough for McLaren to take a calculated risk on the 2021 Indy Lights runner-up, recognizing his potential for future growth within the team.
Colton Herta endured a largely disappointing year for his high standards and those of Andretti Autosport. He had genuine opportunities to win races at venues like Road America and Mid-Ohio, but these chances regrettably slipped through his grasp, leaving him winless for the season. Romain Grosjean, another Andretti driver, started the year strongly, showcasing his characteristic aggression and speed. However, his promising early form completely unraveled after the pivotal month of May, culminating in his surprising departure from Andretti at the end of the season – a decision believed to be driven by factors beyond a mere lack of performance, indicating deeper internal issues.
Ironically, Grosjean was later extended a lifeline following Juncos Hollinger Racing’s perplexing and controversial decision to drop Callum Ilott after a solid and competitive second season. The rift between Ilott and team owner Ricardo Juncos was widely rumored to have formed well before the on-track collision between Ilott and teammate Agustin Canapino at Laguna Seca. The timing of this severance left Ilott in a difficult position, effectively frozen out of a full-time seat for the 2024 season despite his evident talent and consistent performances.
Marcus Armstrong earned the Rookie of the Year honors in what was a relatively thin class, despite exclusively competing on road and street courses. Beyond a missed podium opportunity at Road America, the former F2 driver and popular podcast host delivered solid, if unspectacular, results, showcasing his professional approach and steady hands. Finally, Linus Lundqvist, the reigning Indy NXT champion, needed just three relief appearances late in the season to profoundly impress Chip Ganassi Racing. His immediate adaptation and strong performances were more than enough to convince the legendary team owner, subsequently earning him the well-deserved full-time opportunity in IndyCar that many felt he had merited all along, signaling another exciting prospect for the future of the series.
Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter andgo ad-free
IndyCar
- IndyCar driver McLaughlin cleared of injury after crashing through barrier at Barber
- Schumacher says his IndyCar feels like ‘an F2 car, just with better tyres’
- IndyCar “way faster than Formula 1” in some corners, says Grosjean
- FIA to award more F1 superlicence points to IndyCar drivers from 2026
- Schumacher to race full-time in IndyCar with RLL in 2026
Browse all IndyCar articles