Nico Hulkenberg’s Formula 1 journey has often been characterized by moments of immense promise frequently overshadowed by a perplexing inability to convert potential into tangible podium finishes. His 2019 season at Renault proved to be a microcosm of his career, an ultimately frustrating campaign that culminated in the confirmation of his departure from the team and, for a time, from the sport itself. This year, the familiar narrative of missed opportunities played out once more, leading to Renault’s decision not to retain his services for the 2020 season.
Advert | Become a Supporter & go ad-free
The crushing nadir of Hulkenberg’s 2019 season, a moment that encapsulated his career-long struggle, arrived with agonizing irony at his home race, the German Grand Prix. While he wasn’t firmly entrenched in a top-three position when his car famously twirled on the treacherously slippery run-off area between the final two corners, he was unequivocally in a strong contention for a podium finish – an elusive achievement that, mystifyingly, had managed to evade him throughout his decade-long tenure in Formula 1. The Hockenheimring incident served as a cruel reminder of the fine margins in F1 and the enduring ‘Hulkenberg curse’ that seemed to follow him, turning promising positions into moments of despair. The erratic weather conditions that day presented a chaotic race filled with opportunities, and for a fleeting period, it seemed as though the stars might finally align for the German driver. His error, though minor in execution, carried monumental consequences, snatching away what could have been a career-defining moment at the most emotionally charged venue.
For his third season with the French outfit, Hulkenberg faced a significant new challenge in the form of his highly-regarded teammate, Daniel Ricciardo. The arrival of the charismatic Australian, a multiple race-winner and a driver known for his formidable pace and aggressive overtaking prowess, marked the first time in several seasons that Hulkenberg was truly measured against a contemporary F1 race-winner. This change in dynamic, bringing a fresh benchmark into the garage, proved to be telling and arguably cast Hulkenberg’s performance in a new, often less flattering, light.
The direct comparison between the two drivers began immediately, with Hulkenberg managing to out-qualify Ricciardo in their inaugural race together in Melbourne. However, this early triumph was quickly overshadowed. Ricciardo then proceeded to dominate the qualifying head-to-head, besting his teammate in the subsequent seven qualifying sessions. While the margin between them was at times painstakingly fractional – a mere four-thousandths of a second in China, for example – the consistency of Ricciardo’s advantage painted a clear picture. It became increasingly evident which driver was setting the benchmark for the Renault R.S.19’s performance, and it was not the one who had been intimately familiar with the team’s machinery for the preceding two seasons. Hulkenberg, unfortunately, compounded his own difficulties early in the season, notably with a significant crash during qualifying in Spain, which resulted in the costly destruction of his new-specification front wing, further highlighting moments of pressure-induced errors.
The disparity in race results between the pair largely mirrored their qualifying battle, though both drivers and the team as a whole struggled significantly with the R.S.19’s often-poor reliability compared to their midfield rivals. While Hulkenberg frequently found himself trailing his teammate at the chequered flag, it was generally not by an overwhelming margin, often reflecting the tight battles within the midfield pack rather than a vast difference in raw pace. However, a significant differentiator was Hulkenberg’s inability to ever truly lead the midfield home – a feat Ricciardo achieved on several occasions. There were also instances where the team strategically intervened, either through pit stop timings or direct radio calls, to dictate the running order of their two cars, sometimes to Hulkenberg’s disadvantage, reflecting the perceived pecking order within the team.
By the time the Formula 1 championship reconvened at the iconic Spa-Francorchamps circuit for the Belgian Grand Prix, the news that had been simmering in the paddock for weeks was officially confirmed: Renault had decided that Hulkenberg would make way for the returning Esteban Ocon in the team’s 2020 driver line-up. This announcement delivered a significant blow to Hulkenberg, who then faced the unenviable task of completing the remainder of the season knowing his future in Formula 1 was hanging by the thinnest of threads, with dwindling hopes of securing a seat anywhere else. Despite this immense pressure and the looming uncertainty, Hulkenberg demonstrated remarkable resilience and professionalism, continuing to perform at a commendably high level.
Nico Hulkenberg |
|
|---|---|
| Beat team mate in qualifying | 7/21 |
| Beat team mate in race | 5/15 |
| Races finished | 18/21 |
| Laps spent ahead of team mate | 392/1078 |
| Qualifying margin | +0.07s |
| Points | 37 |
Indeed, in the latter part of the season, after the announcement of his departure, Hulkenberg showcased flashes of his undeniable talent. He managed to out-qualify Ricciardo on several further occasions and delivered a strong race performance in Sochi, beating his teammate to the chequered flag. While he often found himself further behind Ricciardo by the end of races, there were mitigating circumstances, such as the chaotic final lap of the Mexican Grand Prix where Daniil Kvyat’s aggressive shunt denied him a stronger points finish, highlighting how external factors sometimes played a role in his final standings.
As the 2019 season drew to a close and the reality of his future became unequivocally clear, Hulkenberg adopted a notably resigned and philosophical air regarding his fate. In post-race interviews and public statements, he suggested that his eventual loss of a place at Renault was not solely attributable to his on-track performance. Instead, he alluded to broader factors at play, specifically mentioning the strategic and commercial attractiveness to Renault of being represented by a French driver, referring, of course, to Esteban Ocon. This perspective offers a nuanced view, acknowledging the complex interplay of sporting merit, nationality, and marketing appeal that often influences driver decisions in modern Formula 1.
While his 2019 campaign was far from a complete disaster – Hulkenberg still demonstrated flashes of speed and skill – it equally failed to showcase the kind of consistent, team-leading potential that would have unequivocally justified the team retaining him alongside Ricciardo. The direct comparison with a proven race-winner highlighted areas where improvement was needed, particularly in consistently extracting maximum performance over a full race weekend. Ultimately, his enforced departure from Renault – and, as it transpired, from the Formula 1 grid for the immediate future – served as a cumulative verdict, not just on his performance in the 2019 season, but arguably on his entire career trajectory and the unfulfilled promise that became a hallmark of his time in the pinnacle of motorsport. Despite his undeniable talent and remarkable consistency as a points scorer, the lack of a podium finish, coupled with the arrival of new talent and strategic team imperatives, meant his F1 chapter concluded in a manner many found bittersweet.
Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter andgo ad-free
Over to you
What’s your ultimate verdict on Nico Hulkenberg’s 2019 season and his overall Formula 1 career? Which drivers, in your opinion, did he perform better or worse than during his time on the grid? Share your insights and perspectives in the comments section below.
Vote for your 2019 F1 Driver of the Year
Participate in our annual poll and cast your vote for the standout performer of the 2019 Formula 1 season here:
- Vote for your 2019 F1 Driver of the Year
Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter andgo ad-free
2019 F1 Season Review
- ‘I should have done a better job. There’s things that I know I can do better’
- ‘I am definitely not a rookie anymore – but I’m still getting better’
- ‘I didn’t believe in myself much. But after Australia and Bahrain and I gained a lot of confidence’
- ‘It was my best season for sure so far in terms of pure results and speed’
- ‘There’s been plenty of good performances – but there’s also other years I’ve performed at my best’
Browse all 2019 F1 season review articles