A recent shift in the Formula 1 landscape has seen McLaren take the lead in the Constructors’ Championship, a significant milestone that has reignited the title fight. This remarkable achievement naturally raises a compelling question: Does McLaren currently boast the optimal blend of car, team strategy, and driver talent in Formula 1? While their surge to the top is undeniable, a detailed examination of the season’s performance metrics and individual driver battles offers a more comprehensive perspective on their true standing in the fiercely competitive 2024 season.

McLaren’s Dominant Trajectory vs. Red Bull’s Initial Edge

Initially, the Red Bull RB20 appeared to be the benchmark, showcasing superior single-lap pace across the first 18 rounds of the championship. Their consistent speed in qualifying set them apart early on. However, the narrative has evolved dramatically. McLaren’s MCL38, through continuous and aggressive development, has undergone a profound transformation. What was once a minor performance deficit has narrowed considerably, with the MCL38 now only fractionally slower on average over the entire season. More critically, McLaren has been the demonstrably quicker team across the last seven consecutive Grand Prix events. This sustained improvement is a testament to McLaren’s engineering prowess and strategic development, positioning them as a genuine front-runner and a formidable challenger for both championships.

Max Verstappen’s Unyielding Lead and Sergio Perez’s Struggles

Despite McLaren’s ascendance in the Constructors’ standings, the Drivers’ Championship remains largely under the control of Max Verstappen. His commanding lead in the individual points tally is a stark reflection of his exceptional talent and Red Bull’s potent package, particularly in his hands. This formidable advantage, however, highlights the considerable underperformance of his teammate, Sergio Perez. Having fallen to eighth place, Perez is now separated from Verstappen by every driver from rival teams McLaren, Ferrari, and Mercedes. This significant disparity within the Red Bull garage has directly impacted their Constructors’ campaign, providing an opening that McLaren has been quick to exploit.

Lando Norris: A Contender Plagued by Missed Opportunities

Lando Norris, fresh from his triumph at the Singapore Grand Prix, leads McLaren’s charge against Verstappen. His raw pace and the MCL38’s enhanced capabilities have solidified his position as a consistent front-runner. Yet, with a 52-point gap separating him from Verstappen, his quest for the Drivers’ title remains a formidable challenge, albeit one not entirely out of reach in the unpredictable world of F1. Emerging from the summer break with a daunting 78-point deficit, Norris embarked on a crucial four-race stretch, determined to capitalize on every chance to diminish Verstappen’s lead. He delivered spectacularly, out-scoring his rival in each of those pivotal events, showcasing his resilience and McLaren’s growing competitive edge.

However, the question lingers: could Norris have achieved even more? The season has been punctuated by instances where valuable points slipped through his grasp. At Baku, for example, adverse circumstances beyond his control impacted his performance. Similarly, at Monza, a race where McLaren demonstrated potential to win, teammate Oscar Piastri finished ahead in second place. Had circumstances aligned differently, either McLaren driver could have clinched the victory. While it’s inherently subjective to dissect every “what if”—such as precisely calculating his finish position 44 laps after a lap-one gravel trap incident at Spa—these cumulative missed opportunities undeniably contribute to his current championship deficit. Maximizing every available point is crucial in a title fight, and Norris has left some on the table.

Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter andgo ad-free

The “Max McLaren” Hypothesis: A Theoretical Championship Lead for Norris

To quantify the impact of these missed opportunities, a robust analytical approach involves examining the maximum points scored by each team’s car at every race. Max Verstappen’s record illustrates near-flawless consistency; his teammate only out-scored him once, due to a car breakdown in Australia. This demonstrates Verstappen’s remarkable ability to extract the absolute peak performance from his machinery, race after race.

Lando Norris’s situation is notably different. He has been out-scored by his talented teammate, Oscar Piastri, in nine of the 21 competitive rounds this season (encompassing 18 Grand Prix races and three Sprint events). This leads to an intriguing hypothetical: if Norris had consistently achieved the best result between the two McLaren drivers, mirroring Verstappen’s relentless maximization of points for Red Bull, would his current 52-point deficit be significantly less? The answer is a striking yes.

Under this compelling ‘Max McLaren’ scenario, there would, in fact, be no deficit whatsoever. If either McLaren driver had consistently secured the team’s top result in every race – effectively representing an optimal McLaren performance – that hypothetical ‘Max McLaren’ driver would be leading Max Verstappen by an impressive 13 points. This analysis powerfully suggests that had Norris capitalized on the instances where Piastri outperformed him, he could have seized the championship lead from Verstappen, potentially as early as the Azerbaijan Grand Prix. It underscores the immense potential that has been within McLaren’s grasp throughout the season.

Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter andgo ad-free

Navigating the Nuances and Realities of the F1 Championship

While the ‘Max McLaren’ hypothetical provides fascinating insights, it’s crucial to consider the inherent complexities and unpredictable nature of Formula 1. For instance, the Azerbaijan Grand Prix presented its own set of challenges, with Norris suffering the misfortune of a brief yellow flag during Q1. Such an incident, beyond a driver’s control, can significantly compromise qualifying position and, consequently, race strategy and outcome. These twists of fate are an integral part of F1, often shaping results in unforeseen ways.

Moreover, some of Piastri’s superior results were directly influenced by events impacting Norris’s race. A notable example is the Austrian Grand Prix, where Norris and Verstappen collided while fiercely contesting the lead. This incident, while detrimental to Norris’s race, inadvertently elevated Piastri to a strong second-place finish. These moments underscore that while a simple numerical projection might place Norris in the championship lead, the intricate and often chaotic reality of F1 racing doesn’t always align perfectly with theoretical calculations. Nevertheless, the underlying truth remains clear: Norris could, and arguably should, be considerably closer than 52 points to Verstappen in the Drivers’ Championship.

Oscar Piastri: McLaren’s Rising Star and Norris’s Internal Rival

Oscar Piastri’s emergence as a consistent, high-performing driver has undoubtedly added an intriguing dynamic to the McLaren team, posing a genuine challenge and perhaps even a “headache” for Lando Norris. The young Australian’s rapid progression has been nothing short of spectacular. It was recently pointed out to Piastri that he has accumulated the most points of any driver over the last nine races. Displaying characteristic modesty, Piastri expressed skepticism, telling Auto Motor und Sport, “I don’t believe in these calculations. Some other driver has probably scored the most points from the last eight or the last ten races.”

Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter andgo ad-free

However, the statistical evidence firmly contradicts Piastri’s humble assessment. In reality, Oscar Piastri has indeed amassed the highest points total over both the last eight and ten races. Furthermore, extending this detailed analysis across the entirety of the season reveals that Piastri has more frequently been the top points scorer in the field than any other driver. This consistent, high-level performance from Piastri speaks volumes about his exceptional talent, adaptability, and his capacity to maximize race weekends, solidifying his position as one of F1’s most exciting young talents and a formidable internal rival for Norris.

Most Points Scored Over Recent F1 Rounds (2024 Season)

Number of most recent rounds	Driver/s who scored most points	Score
2	Oscar Piastri	40
3	Oscar Piastri	58
4	Lando Norris	80
5	Lando Norris	90
6	Oscar Piastri	113
7	Oscar Piastri	125
8	Oscar Piastri	150
9	Oscar Piastri	156
10	Oscar Piastri	166
11	Oscar Piastri	187
12	Oscar Piastri and Lando Norris	198
13	Lando Norris and Max Verstappen	221
14	Max Verstappen	254
15	Max Verstappen	280
16	Max Verstappen	280
17	Max Verstappen	305
18	Max Verstappen	331

A significant observation from this analysis is that Piastri became the highest points-scorer in the entire field at the 12-race mark. This critical juncture coincided with the Emilia-Romagna Grand Prix, where Piastri first benefited from the same crucial car upgrade that Norris had used in the preceding round in Miami, a race Norris sensationally won. This highlights Piastri’s remarkable ability to immediately extract maximum performance from improved machinery, further emphasizing his growing stature in Formula 1.

The Road Ahead: Championship Fate and The Cost of Missed Opportunities

As the thrilling 2024 Formula 1 season draws towards its climax, despite his recent exceptional form, Lando Norris faces an uphill battle to catch Max Verstappen in the Drivers’ Championship. Should he ultimately fall short, the season will undoubtedly be remembered for a series of missed opportunities that, in hindsight, could have proven decisive. Every single point not secured, every race where the optimal result was just out of reach, has contributed to his current deficit. The ongoing narrative of the 2024 F1 season is thus not merely about who eventually claims the titles, but also about the razor-thin margins and the pivotal “what-if” moments that ultimately shape the outcome. While McLaren’s lead in the Constructors’ Championship proudly reflects their collective strength and development, the individual Drivers’ Championship battle continues to be a compelling and complex story of talent, strategy, and opportunity.

How will the 2024 championship be decided? Examine every possible outcome using the F1 championship calculator

Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter andgo ad-free

More from Formula 1

• Was F1’s “Greatest Race Ever” Truly 15 Years Ago?
• Domenicali Defends F1 Overtaking: “Overtaking is Overtaking”
• F1’s Crash Prevention Efforts: Rare But Obvious Dangers
• F1 Return to India Post-2027: A Hopeful Prospect?
• Verstappen Dislikes New F1 Cars – How Do Rivals Feel?

Browse all Formula 1 articles