FIA Unveils Race Watch System for Penalty Consistency

The FIA recently offered unprecedented insights into its innovative ‘Race Watch’ stewarding system, a move prompted by complaints from Romain Grosjean following a controversial penalty he received at the French Grand Prix. RaceFans’ correspondent, @DieterRencken, meticulously observed the system’s practical application and its broader implications during day two of the Austrian Grand Prix, offering a detailed perspective on F1’s evolving approach to race officiating.

8am Friday: Arrival at the Red Bull Ring

Settling into a compact yet comfortable apartment nestled on the high street of Knittelfeld, a charming Austrian town, I found myself ideally situated just four miles from the Red Bull Ring. This proximity ensured a remarkably tranquil and leisurely drive to the circuit, a welcome departure from the typical Grand Prix commute. Despite the Red Bull Ring’s storied past, evolving from the original Zeltweg to the Österreichring, then the A1 Ring, and now its current iteration, and its picturesque location amidst the foothills of the majestic Austrian Alps, traffic issues were virtually non-existent. Officials, with warm smiles and efficient gestures, either waved me through designated checkpoints or courteously directed me to the correct parking areas, setting a positive tone for the day.

This seamless entry experience stood in stark contrast to the preceding French Grand Prix at Circuit Paul Ricard. A mere week prior in Le Castellet, navigating the circuit’s periphery had been an exercise in sheer frustration, where even valid credentials and a clear destination often led to chaotic delays and a palpable sense of disorganization. While both circuits boast a heritage stretching back at least three decades, the operational disparities could not be more stark. The Red Bull Ring benefits from close proximity to a major motorway, yet even the secondary access roads handled the influx of visitors with admirable efficiency. The ample and clearly marked parking facilities, coupled with the overall atmosphere of calm competence, underscored a truly effective event management strategy.

9am: Paddock Stroll and Circuit Philosophy

After a typically Austrian breakfast – a delightful spread of fresh yoghurt, assorted fruits, thinly sliced cured meats, fine cheeses, wholesome rye bread, and robust coffee – I embarked on my customary walk through the paddock. The crisp, invigorating mountain air filled my lungs, and against the backdrop of the stunning Styrian landscape, all felt right in the vibrant world of Formula 1. This tranquil morning offered a moment for reflection on the sport’s current trajectory.

Despite Formula 1’s ongoing drive towards “modernisation” and embracing new markets, the recent calendar has featured a series of truly traditional circuits since Baku. Barcelona, Monaco, Montreal, the returning Paul Ricard (despite its modern overhaul), and now the Red Bull Ring have all hosted races. Looking ahead, classic venues like Silverstone, Hockenheim, Spa-Francorchamps, and Monza are still on the horizon before the championship heads to the urban spectacle of Singapore. Even Suzuka and Interlagos, while interspersed with more “showcase” events, retain an undeniable classic appeal, and the Mexican Grand Prix, despite its layout modifications, still evokes a traditional racing spirit.

A striking commonality among most of these circuits is their consistent delivery of top-tier racing action. This begs the question: is it intrinsically linked to topography? Many traditional circuits masterfully follow the natural undulations and contours of the land, almost as if pioneering track designers, much like farmers tilling the soil, allowed the landscape to dictate the initial carvings, with architects later refining these plans to incorporate evolving safety standards. In contrast, many contemporary “super-stadium” circuits are often constructed on vast, flat expanses of land, their layouts determined more by property boundaries and commercial considerations than by the organic flow of the terrain. The Red Bull Ring, with its undulating elevation changes and natural curves, serves as a prime example of how a circuit intrinsically linked to its environment can consistently produce thrilling and unpredictable racing.

11am: First Practice and F1 Vision

As the clock struck eleven, marking the commencement of Free Practice 1, I settled in to follow the session on my F1 Vision device. Many readers may have noticed that our Austrian Grand Prix coverage is proudly supported by F1 Vision, an ingenious hand-held device specifically designed to elevate the circuit experience for fans. This portable unit acts as a personal gateway to the pit wall, allowing spectators to immerse themselves in the proceedings with unparalleled access. Its multi-lingual in-ear commentary offers a choice between live circuit commentary or various television audio feeds, ensuring every nuance of the race is captured. Furthermore, a comprehensive menu of channels provides a rich array of feeds, including captivating in-car footage from select drivers and real-time data overlays, giving fans a truly insider’s perspective on the action unfolding on track.

We are currently preparing a comprehensive review of the new, 2018-specification F1 Vision device, which promises even greater enhancements and features. For those contemplating attending a Formula 1 race in the near future and wishing to amplify their on-site experience, I highly recommend exploring the capabilities of this device. You can find more information about F1 Vision and its offerings here, and prepare to witness the Grand Prix like never before.

2pm: Paddock Lunch and Press Conference Insights

Following the FIA’s customary Friday press conference, a well-deserved lunch awaited at the Mercedes hospitality suite. The menu featured a delicious red snapper accompanied by creamy mashed potatoes, followed by a refreshing fruit salad and a classic Austrian apple strudel. This provided a brief respite before the day’s first round of interview sessions began. Our schedule kicked off with Robert Kubica, fresh from his Free Practice 1 outing with Williams, followed by a grilling session with Sauber team principal Fred Vasseur, both providing fascinating insights into their respective situations.

Kubica’s candidness about his aspirations was poignant. He openly admitted his fervent hope for a full-time return to an F1 cockpit, yet acknowledged that his options were slowly but inexorably receding. The question lingers: will the motorsport world ever again witness the immense talent of the Pole, a driver Fernando Alonso once rated as his equal before the devastating rally crash that almost severed his arm? It would be a tragic waste of a once-in-a-generation talent, yet the harsh realities of Formula 1 demand a pragmatic outlook, and the window of opportunity for Kubica appears to be closing rapidly.

Fred Vasseur’s interview, however, proved to be a masterclass in paddock intrigue. When pressed about the persistent rumors of an approach from Ferrari regarding Charles Leclerc’s future, the Frenchman initially flatly refused to respond verbally, instead shaking his head three times when asked directly. His eventual, terse ‘No’ therefore seemed unconvincing, leaving journalists in the room to ponder the true meaning of his reluctance. After the session concluded, one veteran journalist speculated whether Vasseur’s initial refusal to utter a single word was a deliberate tactical maneuver – ensuring no audiotape or transcript of a direct denial would exist – or simply a manifestation of the immense pressure he was undoubtedly under regarding his star protégé. Such subtle exchanges are often more revealing than any direct statement in the high-stakes world of F1 paddock politics.

5:30pm: Demystifying Race Watch with Charlie Whiting

The afternoon’s most illuminating session came courtesy of Race Director Charlie Whiting, who provided an extensive and highly informative explanation of the background and methodology behind the stewards’ decision regarding Romain Grosjean’s “nonsense” penalty in France. Having personally reviewed the overhead footage of the incident, my prior doubts were entirely dispelled; I became convinced that the stewards had indeed handed down the correct decision. More importantly, Whiting’s detailed presentation allowed me to gain a far deeper and more comprehensive understanding of the sophisticated ‘Race Watch’ process now employed by the stewards to ensure consistent and fair officiating.

Traditional Austrian fare
Traditional Austrian fare served during the Grand Prix weekend.

The Race Watch system is a comprehensive digital database that meticulously catalogues all incidents that have occurred over the past four years in Formula 1. This powerful tool can be efficiently sorted by various parameters, including the specific offence, the stewards’ previous decisions, the implicated driver, the event, and the applicable regulation. This allows stewards to quickly retrieve and compare historical precedents for virtually any on-track transgression. All salient details, including crucial video footage and telemetry data, can be accessed with a mere click of a mouse. In most instances, such compelling material is presented directly to drivers during stewards’ enquiries, providing irrefutable evidence and fostering greater understanding. In Grosjean’s specific case, however, the penalty was issued during the intense heat of the race itself, meaning he had not yet had the opportunity to review the footage – a key factor in his initial confusion and frustration. The FIA’s commitment to demonstrating this system highlights a significant step towards enhanced transparency and consistency in F1 stewarding, aiming to minimize future misunderstandings and ensure a level playing field.

8pm: Evening Reflections and a Motorsport Legend

After the last of the day’s interviews concluded, it was time for dinner in the bustling media centre. The evening’s fare was a hearty Fleischtopf, a delightful Austrian dish akin to a rich stew-soup hybrid, packed with tender meat and nourishing vegetables. Over dinner, I had the immense privilege of engaging in a captivating conversation with Marie-Claude Beaumont, a renowned F1 photographer whose impressive career also includes a formidable past as a race and rally competitor. Beaumont regaled me with vivid anecdotes from her racing days, particularly her experiences behind the wheel of a Corvette at Le Mans, which she affectionately described as a “lovely car, but heavy to brake at the end of the straight.” She also shared insights from her time sharing a Porsche with the legendary Didier Pironi in the grueling 24 Hours classic, offering a frank assessment of him as “selfish” and “crazy” – a testament to the raw, unfiltered nature of racing in that era.

Our conversation was truly wonderful, offering a rare glimpse into the golden age of motorsport through the eyes of someone who lived and breathed it. It was a fitting and truly enjoyable end to a day packed with fascinating insights and unexpected encounters. For those intrigued by Marie-Claude Beaumont’s extraordinary life and career, I highly recommend checking out this insightful interview with Marie to discover more about her remarkable journey.

Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter andgo ad-free

2018 Austrian Grand Prix

  • 2018 Austrian Grand Prix Star Performers
  • Four wins, no poles: Verstappen equals an unusual record
  • Top ten pictures from the 2018 Austrian Grand Prix
  • Error-free Verstappen hands Red Bull a home win
  • Why the Red Bull Ring showed Paul Ricard how to run a race

Browse all 2018 Austrian Grand Prix articles