The Ultimate Quest: Who Will Conquer Motorsports’ Elusive Triple Crown – Alonso or Montoya?

The Triple Crown of Motorsports stands as one of the most revered and challenging achievements in the history of racing. Comprising victories in the Monaco Grand Prix, the Le Mans 24 Hours, and the Indianapolis 500, it represents the pinnacle of versatility and skill across vastly different disciplines. Only one driver, Graham Hill, has ever completed this extraordinary feat. Today, two modern legends, Fernando Alonso and Juan Pablo Montoya, are each just one win away from etching their names alongside Hill in racing immortality. The burning question: who will get there first?

Recent comments from the reigning Indianapolis 500 winner, Simon Pagenaud, have reignited the debate, with the Frenchman offering a compelling perspective on which of these titans is more likely to achieve the ultimate racing glory. According to Pagenaud, his Penske sportscar teammate, Juan Pablo Montoya, holds a distinct advantage in this high-stakes race against time and talent.

Understanding the Triple Crown: A Trifecta of Triumph

Before delving into the prospects of Alonso and Montoya, it’s essential to appreciate the sheer difficulty and prestige of the Triple Crown. Each leg demands a unique blend of attributes:

• Monaco Grand Prix: The jewel in the Formula 1 crown, Monaco is a test of precision, nerve, and unwavering focus on the unforgiving street circuit. Its narrow, winding layout offers minimal overtaking opportunities, placing immense pressure on qualifying performance and strategic brilliance. A victory here is a testament to a driver’s raw speed and car control in the most glamorous and demanding environment F1 has to offer.
• Le Mans 24 Hours: The epitome of endurance racing, Le Mans is a brutal test of speed, reliability, and teamwork over 24 grueling hours. Drivers must master high-speed sections, navigate traffic with varying car classes, and maintain mental and physical stamina through day and night. It requires not just individual prowess but seamless collaboration with teammates and an entire pit crew.
• Indianapolis 500: “The Greatest Spectacle in Racing,” the Indy 500 is an oval racing behemoth defined by incredible speeds, strategic fuel management, and the terrifying precision required for drafting and overtaking at over 230 mph. The smallest mistake can lead to catastrophic consequences, and winning demands an innate understanding of aerodynamics, car setup, and the art of racecraft in a pack.

To excel in all three demands an adaptability that few drivers possess, highlighting why Graham Hill remains the sole occupier of this exclusive club.

Fernando Alonso’s Pursuit of Indy Glory

Fernando Alonso, a two-time Formula 1 World Champion, has long made his intentions clear regarding the Triple Crown. His illustrious career includes two victories at the Monaco Grand Prix (2006, 2007), showcasing his mastery of street circuits. He then added two triumphs at the Le Mans 24 Hours (2018, 2019) with Toyota in the dominant LMP1 category, solidifying his status as an endurance racing champion.

The Indianapolis 500 remains the elusive final piece of his puzzle. Alonso’s debut in 2017 was nothing short of spectacular. He quickly adapted to the unique demands of oval racing, leading 27 laps and showcasing remarkable pace for a rookie. Unfortunately, an engine failure cut short what promised to be a truly competitive run. His return in 2019, however, proved to be a humbling experience. Partnering with McLaren for a solo effort, the team struggled with preparation and qualifying speed, resulting in the unthinkable: failure to qualify for the race. This setback underscored the immense challenges and the fine margins involved in conquering the Indy 500, especially for an outfit lacking deep experience in the event.

For Alonso, the path to Indianapolis victory is fraught with complexities. As Simon Pagenaud astutely points out, “Fernando has so much more to learn. So much more he needs to be investing, he needs to have the best engine that year, he needs to have the best team mates to help him out, there’s a lot to do so it’s a lot more complicated.” Beyond the driving skill, securing a front-running package in the highly competitive IndyCar series, particularly for a one-off effort, is a monumental task. The nuances of oval racing setup, race strategy, and the unpredictable nature of the Indy 500 mean that even a driver of Alonso’s caliber needs everything to align perfectly.

Juan Pablo Montoya: A Le Mans Title Away

Juan Pablo Montoya, a former F1 rival of Alonso’s, brings an equally impressive and diverse racing resume to the Triple Crown challenge. Montoya is already a two-time winner of the Indianapolis 500, taking his first victory in 2000 during his CART era and adding a second in 2015 with Team Penske. His natural talent for oval racing and fearless approach make him a formidable force at the Brickyard. He also secured a memorable victory at the Monaco Grand Prix in 2003 during his Formula 1 tenure, demonstrating his capability on street circuits.

Montoya’s missing piece is the Le Mans 24 Hours. He made his sole appearance to date in 2018, competing in an LMP2 car with United Autosports. While he finished a respectable third in class, the LMP2 category is not typically in contention for overall victory, which is the standard for Triple Crown recognition. To achieve the Triple Crown, Montoya would need to secure a drive in a top-tier Hypercar or former LMP1 entry that is capable of outright victory.

Pagenaud’s reasoning for favoring Montoya is compelling: “because Juan Pablo is doing sportscar racing full-time there and he is very good at it.” Montoya’s current involvement in sportscar racing, including appearances in the World Endurance Championship and IMSA, keeps him sharp in the specific demands of endurance events. “Juan Pablo is just as good as he ever was, quite frankly. Put him in any car, he can step in and be competitive right away. He knows the kind of racing that is so he doesn’t have to learn much, he just needs to be in the right situation. And I assure you he would win it. If I was to put him in the right situation I know he could do it, he will get it done.” This highlights Montoya’s adaptability and current immersion in the relevant racing discipline, giving him a potentially smoother path to finding a winning Le Mans drive.

Simon Pagenaud’s Hard-Won Victory and Unique Celebration

The man offering these insights, Simon Pagenaud, knows a thing or two about the relentless pursuit of victory at Indianapolis. It took the Frenchman a demanding eight attempts to finally claim the Borg-Warner Trophy at the Indianapolis 500. His triumph in 2019 was not just a personal milestone but also came with a memorable and unconventional celebration.

Instead of immediately heading to the traditional Victory Lane, Pagenaud broke with convention, driving his car to the start/finish line and celebrating directly with the thousands of fans lining the grandstands. This spontaneous act was a profound gesture of gratitude, a way to thank the supporters who had stood by him throughout his journey, particularly as a foreign driver in a sport often dominated by American talent.

“It was intentional to celebrate with the fans. It was intentional to look at them and thank them for the support,” Pagenaud explained. “The support I have in Indianapolis, for a Frenchman, is incredible. I can’t walk to a restaurant, it’s just nuts.” He highlighted the unique generosity of American racing fans: “People over there, even though you’re a foreigner, some Americans will support you more than you would support an American driver. It’s really surprising. I don’t think it’s the same way in Europe. I want to be thankful for that and grateful.”

This heartfelt appreciation for his fanbase underscores the deep connection drivers can forge with their supporters, especially in iconic events like the Indy 500. Pagenaud’s decision to share that raw moment of triumph with the fans, foregoing immediate official formalities, resonated deeply and was “actually very well received.” His journey and the sincerity of his celebration add another layer of insight into the passion and dedication required to win at the highest levels of motorsports, a passion shared by both Alonso and Montoya in their own quests.

The Continuing Allure of the Triple Crown

The debate between Fernando Alonso and Juan Pablo Montoya encapsulates the enduring appeal of the Triple Crown. It’s not just about individual race wins; it’s about proving ultimate versatility, mastering the most diverse and challenging environments in global motorsport. Both drivers represent different eras and styles, yet both share that singular focus on achieving what only one other has. While Pagenaud believes Montoya has a more straightforward path given his current sportscar commitments, the unpredictable nature of racing means nothing is guaranteed until the checkered flag falls.

The quest continues, captivating fans worldwide as these two motorsport legends strive to write the next chapter in the history of the Triple Crown, forever cementing their places among the pantheon of racing’s greatest.

More IndyCar Insights

• IndyCar driver McLaughlin cleared of injury after crashing through barrier at Barber
• Schumacher says his IndyCar feels like ‘an F2 car, just with better tyres’
• IndyCar “way faster than Formula 1” in some corners, says Grosjean
• FIA to award more F1 superlicence points to IndyCar drivers from 2026
• Schumacher to race full-time in IndyCar with RLL in 2026

Browse all IndyCar articles